Image by: SomeBizarreMonkey
Concert Reviews

Concert Review: Imperfect Offering - The Music Of Leonard Cohen In Auckland

Where: Q Theatre, Auckland NZ
When: 29 Sep 2019
David Boyle

The spirit of Leonard Cohen was woken last Sunday night as he joined the sold-out audience at the intimate Q Theatre in Auckland, NZ to watch Imperfect Offering, an NZ band of musicians dedicated to preserving the legacy of the acclaimed poet and singer-songwriter.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey

Sold out audience at Q's Rangatira performance space

I found Leonard late in his career but was lucky enough to see the man here in Auckland at the Vector Arena (before it was renamed to Spark Arena) in 2013. Like a great bottle of red wine, he had aged better than many of his peers at that concert and influenced probably more than I can count. So it was with great anticipation I turned up at the Q Theatre to see if Imperfect Offering could do the man proud and dance me to the end of love.

The focus of the show was to take the audience on a journey through his music, from his first album, Songs Of Leonard Cohen, all the way through to his final album You Want It Darker, released in 2016. Designed more like a musical tour through his life, the show highlighted certain moments that formed a huge part of Cohen, including Chelsea Hotel, the Zen Buddhist sanctuary of Mount Baldy and, of course, his muse Marianne Ihlen.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4219

Imperfect Offering

With the lights dimmed, the nine-piece band sauntered onto the stage, flooded in a sea of red, all dressed from Johnny Cash’s wardrobe. They took their spots and opened with So Long Marianne and Suzanne, from Songs of Leonard Cohen.

This was followed by the beautiful That’s No Way To Say Goodbye and Bird on the Wire.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4349

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4365

I have to say now this was not a tribute band but a tribute to Leonard and his music. That said, the spirit of Cohen’s music was captured perfectly with the incredible talent of the whole band which included Pete Snow (guitar and balalaika), Nick Jones (violin), Rian Kannemeyer (bass), Nigel Pizzini (rhythm guitar), Paul Naveen (drums) and Ben Fernandez (keyboards).

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9823

Peter McMillan

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9086

Amy Skeates

Singing duties were shared during the course of the evening, with Peter McMillan taking the lead and the weight of not just providing the main vocals, but also the storytelling as he wove intimate anecdotes through the performance. It brought each song to life and was such a great idea, particularly for the uninitiated.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4316

The tempo lifted as the band left the folk songs behind with Famous Blue Raincoat, Who By The Fire and Chelsea Hotel. The latter being a song written just after the tragic death of the one and only Janice Joplin, who Cohen had a brief affair with, which recalled a specific liaison in the Chelsea Hotel. The lyrics and the delivery by the band captured the song perfectly and made a number of the audience chuckle around me when they sang “You were talking so brave and so sweet, giving me head on the unmade bed”. Brilliant.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4207

Thanks to Ruby van Dorp, the lighting for the night was minimalistic and perfect. The silhouettes of the men in the band, all in hats, at times drew you to the back of the stage, almost glimpsing the ghost of the man himself.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4199

Amy Skeates and Clare Martin

Graham Fleury and Tony McMaster on sound have to get a nod here as well. The Q theatre was a perfect place to spotlight the true musicianship of the band and the incredible voices of both Clare Martin and Amy Skeates. The sound had warmth and feeling that flooded over the stage and wrapped the audience like a soft blanket.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4149

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9598

The first half of the evening was finished off with three of my all-time favourites: Dance Me to the End of Love, First We Take Manhattan, and the timeless classic Hallelujah that I am sure brought a tear to the eye as Imperfect Offering captured the spirit of the song beautifully.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4132

Ben Fernandez

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9858

Paul Naveen

A quick break followed, allowing enough time for the punters to chat amongst themselves and get a top-up of their favourite tipple.
I spoke to a lovely young man sitting beside us who was the son (aged nine) of keyboardist Ben Fernandez and who had aspirations, just like his dad, to be on stage, with his favoured instrument being the clarinet.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9540

Rian Kannemeyer

The second half kicked off with Tower of Song, Ain't No Cure for Love (in gripping Americana rock fashion by Amy Skeates!), The Future and In My Secret Life. With such a back catalogue, I wondered how the band chose the songs they played. I’m guessing they were the ones that meant the most to them and also worked to tell the story of the man in music. I later discovered that the setlist is not the same when the band performs in other venues across Aotearoa. 

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4330

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9671

Clare Martin

Clare Martin delivered an outstanding version of Boogie Street, showing her true vocal range with a song that, to me, carried the whispers of music coming from an underground, dimly lit, smoke-filled bar in a back alley where only the cool people hang out.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4444

A special dedication to Brenda

Come Healing was specially dedicated to Peter's wife, Brenda and this song was another incredibly touching highlight of the show. 

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9007

Pete Snow and Nick Jones

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4260

I’ve mentioned the musicianship of the band and they were the real winner on the night. These boys have talent and passion. The attention to detail and the harmonics that glided off the fingers of Pete Snow on his guitars and the bow of Nick Jones' violin were splendid. Each member added to the backdrop perfectly to combine with the singers at the front. At times they also showed off their own singing prowess, adding even more depth to the already deep pool of talent.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4388

I remember the day that I heard Leonard Cohen had passed away and I felt the need to get his last recorded album You Want It Darker. Two tracks from this finished off the set with my favourite, the title track by Nigel Pizzini, highlighting a man that knows the light of day is about to be gone forever.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9757

Nigel Pizzini

A surprise encore followed with I’m Your Man sung in true Cohen style and voice by Peter McMillan, who did a brilliant job, and the whole band converged to deliver You Got Me Singing finishing off the night.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 4537 2

A standing ovation followed by the sell-out crowd, reflecting exactly what I had been thinking during the whole concert.

ImperfectOffering Q Credit SomeBizarreMonkey 9739

Imperfect Offering delivered a show of exceptional quality and passion, tied together by stories and songs from one of the greatest poets and songwriters to ever grace our earth. I’m sure many of the audience went home and dusted off some old vinyl to find the nuggets on display and even the man himself would have given a tip of his hat and a sly smile of approval, which says it all.

69419302 10157262184821257 6829759128974393344 o

Catch Imperfect Offering next at the Baycourt Arts Centre in Tauranga on 04 October. Tickets available at Ticketek.

Radio 13 thanks and credits Reuben from SomeBizarreMonkey Photography for all the images featured on this article. 


Written By: David Boyle David’s day job is head of sales and marketing at Mint Asset Management. It doesn’t sound very rock and roll does it? But don’t be put off, he is passionate about music and has been nearly all his life. Better known as Boylee, he can’t sing a note in tune, remember a complete song lyric, nor play an instrument of any sort, but he does have an eye-opening knowledge of modern music and is never shy to share it with his friends and peers.